3 Idiots (2017) User Reviews

Another romantic comedy

[isaacochoterena · 3/10 · 30 August 2021]

Although it seems like a new and different proposal, it ends up falling into the most common clichés in Mexican films. The main plot is not very well defined, and whatever it was, it ends up being slow and cheesy, it has many unnecessary scenes that do not add anything to the story, some performances are bad, several things are not funny, the love story does not develop . Some characters are poorly written, they even seem like extras, despite that it becomes entertaining, has a good message about following your passions and is not so absurd.

I think that it is highly overrated by the public since everything that happens in the film seems indifferent to me. Simply boring.

Good but not very good

[shreeanshdash · 5/10 · 15 December 2021]

The movie is the remake of 3 idiots but not very lengthy . It is of 1.48hr not bad but also not good. Good music , come to age movie, watch this to your children but there is some comedy which are not comedy but it is unsuitable for child. Some not more. Watch the film. Not worst,not best. Medium.

Please don't see this poor try of movie

[beto_dacl · 1/10 · 22 April 2017]

Bad copy of a great Indian movie. The same recycled actors and actress. The same cheap humor of "the new Mexican cinema"

Please, if you're of another country don't think that Mexicans are as weak as this movie in every sense is.

It's sad because there are a lot of talented young people in my country wishing an opportunity to do something new, but in México all of what matters is the money

"Let's do it all over again, but worst"

[macf-12941 · 2/10 · 14 April 2017]

¡¡SPOILER ALERT!!

Here we go... I saw the original movie last week and it was AMAZING, from the script to the actors and production team. That was a really good movie that caught my attention and actually touched my heart and made me think about what I really wanted to do with my life.

Now... in THIS VERSION (Mexican remake) it looks like these people just took a look at the perfect script and sad "Let's do it all over again, but FREAKING WORST". This movie is AWWWFULL with the exception of some very good camera shots and maybe only ONE good joke. So the "writers" omitted EVERY SINGLE SCENE that makes this movie have sense and connect with the audience. They took away the explanation of why is the pen so important for the principal of the institute (A simple screw because of a death wife... please). They also omitted the explanation of the MOST important line of the movie "All izz well". This movie lacks originality, is a failed attempt to make this movie more "Mexican- like" and so it has to appeal to the last resource of a super boring movie "FART JOKES". The camera shots are just fine despite the fact that the movie appeals to shots of Martha Higareda's butt and boobs (no offense intended). Also in the job interview of "Felipe", the real tension comes from the fact that he is in a wheelchair and the camera centers the actors face instead and "Felipe" gets MAD instead of HUMBLE AND UNDERSTANDING. I REALLY WANTED TO BE SUPPORTIVE OF Mexican CINEMA. BUT THIS MOVIE AS MANY OTHERS FAILED AN ATTEMPT OF BEING AT LEAST GOOD. IT WAS REALLY HARD TO WATCH A VERY GOOD MOVIE (THE ORIGINAL) TURNED INTO AN AWFUL MOVIE.

Dog S Word

[rajesh_pataka_puri · 1/10 · 21 January 2022]

This movie is the most dog s wordest movie I've ever watched by far. The fact that this movie does not at all live up to the standard nor reputation achieved by the original 3 Idiots that it intends to replicate is painfully apparent throughout its entire shortened run time of one hour and forty-five minutes. However, this ends up being one of the few positive features of this film, as I was not forced to endure more of its signature lifeless characters, pointless plot, and borderline racist undertones. This film is devoid of many if not all of the significant scenes and character motivations of the original for the sake of dry and ineffective humor.

To go into specifics:

The scene in the original 3 Idiots in which Joy takes his own life in fear of failing to graduate is absent. In 3 Idiots, this scene indicates an extreme shift in tone which is the first clear representation to the viewer of the mental toll that the university extracts from the students. With this scene missing, the movie now feels void of stakes and it becomes harder to care about the main characters.

Another major change is the removal of "Raju"'s father from the movie in favor of a random cousin who is repeatedly misgendered for a cheap attempt at humor that neither lands nor contributes anything to the story. This is significant because in 3 Idiots, Rancho saving Raju's sick father is the catalyst for their friendship. In 3 Idiotas, the entire scene is very abrupt (his cousin starts choking out of nowhere) and has no emotional weight.

A final change is that Raju's equivalent character makes no attempt on his own life after being rusticated from the University. Instead, he is hit by a car by coincidence, which has no meaning and simply diverts the plot by chance rather than providing the opportunity for character growth realistically. Furthermore, he is incredibly rude in the interview which in this version, convinces the company to hire him. In return, he does not care about getting the job and acts indifferent.

In general, most of the characters are changed from dynamic, and well thought out to shallow, static, lazy humor machines. This is very apparent with Isidoro, who is reduced from a complex character with realistic motivations to an empty shell of a person who does a project on erectile dysfunction and whose entire personality is farting for comic relief (Haha.)

In Conclusion:

3 Idiots takes the time to develop each of the main cast so the viewer feels a personal connection to them and cares what becomes of them by the end. 3 Idiotas, on the other hand, lazily introduces each at the same time in favor of a shorter run time and a few cheap jokes. By the end of the movie, I found myself not caring at all about what happened to any of the characters, and also very distracted by the borderline racist fabricated Indian dances and costumes.

TLDR: If I could give this movie a 0 I would, but sadly I can't, so 1/10 will suffice.

Don't try

[av-42666 · 1/10 · 17 November 2020]

Good try for remake 1×movie but original is 100×movie I am Indian and all Indian 80% people favourite movie 🍿

Watch the original from 2009

[jasonjamesdixon · 1/10 · 13 June 2022]

The Bollywood version is way better and one of my favorite Bollywood movies of all time.

This is wrong on so many levels. Sub par acting carried by the beautiful lead.

It lacked the original story's social economical struggle of India's engineering programs .

Its okay

[sarahschiller-72879 · 6/10 · 31 May 2017]

In general, this film seems an episode of a corny soap opera, at least a well made one, the message they seek to give to the viewer is invaluable. Unfortunately the story wasn't developed in the best way.Anyway I will give it six stars for the pretty woman. Have fun watching it guys!

Would You Believe These Three Idiots Could Save the Planet?

[lavatch · 1/10 · 16 November 2017]

One of the taglines of this film remake is "Dare to be an idiot," and the film actually appears to take itself seriously. From start to finish, "3 Idiots" never finds a narrative rhythm or engages the viewer as either a comedy, a romance, or a drama.

Structurally, the film unfolds as a flashback where some young men search for a long-lost college chum. But the screenplay is so confusing that it is difficult to the difference between timeframes.

For most of the film, it appears as though we are watching a comedy with no laugh lines. Then, the narrative turns very serious when one of the students is struck by a car and is in a coma. The transitions are awkward as we alternate between wild sequences of delivering a baby during a hurricane, a Romeo and Juliet encounter on a balcony, or lame attempts at flatulence jokes.

During the closing credits, biographical profiles crawl across the screen, informing us that what we have just watched was based on a true story of a group of brilliant students who made breakthrough scientific discoveries that aim to save the planet.

Ostensibly, the theme of the film is "passion," as the students' creativity and dedication finally pay off. But the major problem of the film is that we never see the passion. We see infantile behavior, constant highjinks, bad behavior, and no traces of passion.

This should have been a film about dreamers as agents of social change. Instead, it was an exercise in adolescent shenanigans and amateurish screen writing.

Very good remake of the original Indian film

[jack_mortonmorris · 10/10 · 5 June 2017]

I saw the film this past weekend in Austin, Texas with my gal who is from Honduras and the theater had quite a few Espanol speakers in the audience and everyone liked it. It has laughs, seriousness, and sadness and love moments in the script, and I thought the actors did a good job. Who cares if it is a remake? It was made to appeal to a Latin American audience. I think Lionsgate made a wise decision in distributing this film to an American audience, obviously they see something in the film that other critics do not. Do not be swayed by negative criticism and go enjoy the movie, I know I did, and I lived in Chihuahua, Mexico for two years and I am a Gringo and I do not think it is a substandard film from Mexico or a waste of money at all. Go see it and you be the judge.

Desde Chicago Sus Fans

[delapiedraedgar · 10/10 · 2 December 2018]

Congrats guys, well done! Perfect acting for the title and story of the movie. No other actor would have done a great job as your guys. Adding it to my collection!

Nice movie

[aironpiyush · 9/10 · 23 November 2023]

At its core, "3 Idiotas" revolves around the reunion of three college friends-Pancho (Alfonso Dosal), Felipe (Christian Vazquez), and Beto (German Valdez). The narrative unfolds as they embark on a road trip in search of their long-lost friend, Chava (Paulina Davila), who disappeared years ago. The journey becomes a catalyst for self-discovery and a reflection on the unorthodox philosophy imparted by their absent friend during their college days.

One of the film's strengths lies in its ability to balance humor with poignant social commentary. The comedic elements are skillfully woven into the narrative, providing lighthearted moments that resonate with the audience. The chemistry among the lead actors, particularly Dosal, Vazquez, and Valdez, contributes significantly to the film's charm, making their camaraderie both believable and endearing.

Bolado's direction breathes new life into the familiar narrative, infusing it with vibrant Mexican cultural references. The picturesque landscapes and vibrant cinematography enhance the visual appeal, creating a cinematic experience that is both visually engaging and emotionally resonant. The decision to adapt the story to a Mexican context adds layers to the narrative, making it relatable to a broader audience while retaining the essence of the original material.

The film's exploration of the pressure and expectations associated with the education system is particularly relevant. Through the characters' experiences in college, "3 Idiotas" delves into the societal demands placed on individuals to conform to traditional paths of success. The critique of a rigid education system that prioritizes grades over holistic learning is conveyed with humor and sensitivity, prompting viewers to reflect on their own perceptions of success and happiness.

The character dynamics are a highlight of the film. Pancho's rebellious spirit, Felipe's pursuit of artistic passion, and Beto's comedic innocence create a trio that embodies the spirit of non-conformity. Each character undergoes significant growth throughout the journey, and their individual arcs contribute to the overarching theme of self-discovery and authenticity.

The film also introduces a love story that adds a layer of emotion to the narrative. Chava's character serves as a symbol of pursuing one's dreams against societal expectations, and her relationship with Pancho adds a poignant element to the storyline. The romantic subplot is delicately handled, complementing the broader themes of the film without overshadowing the central focus on friendship and self-realization.

Musically, the film embraces a vibrant soundtrack that complements the narrative. The use of music, including popular Mexican tracks, enhances the cultural resonance of the film and contributes to the overall atmosphere. The soundtrack not only accompanies the characters' journey but also becomes a character in itself, evoking a range of emotions that enrich the viewing experience.

In conclusion, "3 Idiotas" (2017) successfully adapts the core elements of the original narrative into a Mexican context, delivering a film that is both entertaining and thought-provoking. Bolado's direction, coupled with the stellar performances of the cast, brings a fresh perspective to the timeless themes of friendship, individuality, and the pursuit of one's passions. The film's ability to seamlessly blend humor with social commentary makes it a standout contribution to the cinematic landscape, resonating with audiences who appreciate a heartfelt and culturally resonant story.