When Matt and Cassie Thorpe's daughter daisy (13) goes missing in a rural New York town, aloof sheriff Paddon and eager deputy Fox point the FBI team to the local outcast, mechanic Curtis Horne, whom everyone in town suspects of the murder of reverend Bryce's teen daughter Amber year earlier. The FBI soon finds reasons to doubt his sole suspect status in both cases, but the locals gang up to lynch Curtis for 'at least' Amber, while it turns out he was exceptionally kind to both girls.
—KGF Vissers