"We Like Mike's" story on paper does sound very ordinary and basic, which may feel rather disappointing for anybody that loved the many complex, twisty episodes Season 7 had that were mostly executed brilliantly. There was no doubt about seeing it on first watch, as Season 7 was on the whole an impressive season and 'Law and Order' proved more than once that it could do a lot with something that doesn't sound overly exciting and make things seem more complex.
Other episodes of Season 7 and 'Law and Order' in general did this a good deal better than "We Like Mike". Which falls short of being one of the best episodes of the season and is a slight disappointment after having such a strong run between "Legacy" and "Double Down". It is still a very good episode that finishes a good deal stronger than it starts, wasn't too enthused to begin with but the more that is revealed things do get more interesting and twistier.
As said, the first quarter or so was not much special. It was competent and intriguing enough, if somewhat on the routine and too simple side as well as predictable. So pretty much what it sounds like on paper.
However, also as said, "We Like Mike" does become more interesting once the whole dilemma with Bodack kicks in and the complexities that come with the case and the tension it causes increase. It no longer becomes too simple, surprises more and lots happens in terms of events and twists without being too complicated. Mike is a very well drawn character that one feels frustration and sympathy for, as one should do for a person in his predicament and a character of his nature.
Can't fault the performances, all the regulars are excellent as is intense and heartfelt Frank John Hughes. The dialogue is thought-provoking and has a pull no punches grit without being heavy-handed.
It is shot with the right amount of intimacy without being claustrophobic and that the editing has become increasingly tighter over-time has been great too. Nice use of locations too. The music doesn't get over-scored or overwrought, even in the more dramatic revelation moments. The direction doesn't try to do too much and is understated but never flat or unsure.
On the whole, very nicely done once it gets going. 8/10.