Mystery!: Cadfael (TV Series) The Holy Thief (1998) User Reviews

Who's gonna get dem bones?

[planktonrules · 8/10 · 1 January 2014]

"The Holy Thief" is a bit unusual in that it does not begin as a murder mystery but is about a theft. Only later in the show does the murder occur. And, it's unusual because it's a follow up from an earlier show "A Morbid Taste for Bones".

The show begins during a torrential rain--and folks are afraid for their lives. In the midst of all the chaos, the Curate, Father Herluin arrives. Herluin was the leader of a nearby abbey--and abbey that was burned down during the recent civil war. According to Herluin, his assistant, Tutulo, had a vision of St. Winifred--therefore the bones of this dead lady (owned by Cadfael's abbey) are now theirs! It was VERY easy for the viewer to hate Herluin...very easy. And, surprisingly, he was NOT murdered. I say surprisingly because most of the time in this series, the rich and obnoxious guy is murdered! So how does Cadfael get involved with his super sleuthy skills? Well, someone tries to steal the holy bones--and in the process a young slave is kidnapped. Only later does someone end up dead--and Cadfael (as usual) believes that the man being blamed is innocent.

This is a pretty typical sort of installment of Cadfael. This means the acting and look of the Middle Ages are quite nice and the story interesting BUT very confusing if you aren't paying close attention. Worth seeing. However, if you saw "A Morbid Taste for Bones", then you'll have a laugh about the whole thing...but I can't say more, as it would ruin "A Morbid Taste for Bones" if you haven't seen it.

Fine use of religious elements and several mysteries for Cadfael to solve

[equesrosa · 7/10 · 20 June 2010]

Perhaps not Cadfael's strongest effort as a detective but fascinating nonetheless as near-continuous rain, thunderstorms and rising waters threaten to swamp Shrewsbury and environs. There was some fine interplay between Derek Jacobi and the guest stars - an arrogant lord exerting his property rights, an equally arrogant prior in search of a favor, yet another novice hearing voices and seeing visions and a slave girl with an angel's voice.

One unusual thing about the episode was it began with a voice-over narration. I'd have thought that by the start of this final season of Cadfael, viewers would have enough sense of the time and place to render the narration superfluous. A minor quibble -- very distinct shadows on the ground in some scenes where it was absolutely pouring rain.

A complaint - background music that became intrusive, perhaps because rather than the instrumental music, this episode featured a lot vocal music. At times it went on long enough to appear to be substituting for dialog or scene changes. The music was lovely and the voices superb but the end result was noisy what with the storms, the sloshing around, the wagon and horses, etc.

"Everyone belongs in the house of God"

[Bernie4444 · 10/10 · 15 October 2023]

This Cadfael story is said to be darker in character and not as much as lighter earlier mysteries. This is not my favorite Hugh Beringar (Anthony Green.) I prefer Eoin McCarthy. However, he works well in this Cadfael. In The Holy Thief, while most people were using trial by water to catch the guilty, Cadfael (Derek Jacobi) uses forensics to track down the murder.

The abbey in Ramsey was burned down by rebel soldiers. You may recall the time of the civil war between King Stephen and Queen Maude. As is the custom they clam the loan of St. Winifred's holy relics, to help build their monastery. You may also recall in "A Morbid Taste for Bones" the trouble Shrewsbury had obtaining St. Winifred. So instead, Brother Cadfael and Abbot Radulfus offer precious gems.

A stormy night comes up and, in the disarray, Winifred is pinched. In the process, there is a murder. Only the balance and counterbalance of Cadfael and Beringar can solve this if anyone can.

The Holy Thief

[Prismark10 · 6/10 · 2 May 2020]

This one is linked to an earlier episode. A Morbid Taste for Bones where a monk had visions so they when off to Wales to recover the remains of martyred St Winifred.

However the bones never left Wales as Cadfael had made a switch.

Now Father Herluin arrives. His abbey has burnt down in the recent civil war and his monk has had a vision that the bones of St Winifred belongs to them.

Father Herluin is successful in getting the bones albeit on a temporary basis. On the way back there is an attempt to steal the bones, jewellery and a slave woman who nearly drowns.

Lord Beaumont, the owner of the land where this all happens now also lay claim to the bones. However he is also mesmerised by the slave woman who he has lusted after.

Cadfael believes that Lord Beaumont wanted to abduct her for himself.

Father Herluin is another obnoxious priest who arrives into Shrewsbury, at least he does not die.

There is a death and Brother Jerome owns up to it, only for Cadfael to sadly exonerate him.

The episode takes place in bad weather, there is a storm which explains part of the episode. The attempt to steal led to something going wrong.

Cadfael does a lot of sleuthing here. There is less emphasis on his personal life. It really is a case of him picking up clues, however threadbare they are.

Justice is dispensed in its usual way in Shrewsbury, trial by drowning.

Anthony Green takes over as Hugh Beringar, who looks more like Sean Pertwee.

it warms up, but not the best episode

[treebeardman · 6/10 · 17 October 2006]

It starts slow, with a bit about the civil war (Empress Matilda versus Stephen) and a determined Prior. The area is in danger of flooding, the roof abbey roof is leaking. Then we get to the murder. Also a singing slave girl is stolen and nearly killed, her owner also sings as part of their act. The remains of a saint that brings pilgrims to the Abbey are also taken, as are jewels given by a dying patroness to rebuild a distant Abbey. There is a trial by water where the innocent sink, the guilty float and get their hand chopped off if they are liars, hung if murderers. Then a trial to see who gets to keep the saints remains by opening the bible at random and reading the passage and judging its relevance. Cadfael does the business as usual, solving mysteries with medieval forensic science and psychology. Its lots of fun.

Technically terrible

[jamison0601 · 6/10 · 14 July 2020]

What could have been a really good episode was severely hampered by terrible editing. The plot was good, and Cadfael's sleuthing excellent. But the edits were so sharp and did time jumps so quickly, it was sometimes difficult to follow. We found ourselves saying "that doesnt make any sense", or "wait, how did she get out of there without being seen" etc, numerous times. Unusual for a normally really well done show.

But, it's Cadfael. Always enjoyable, and the last 30 minutes or so seemed to level out. Derek Jacobi, perfection in the role as always.